Above Ground VS Inground Pool: Which is Better?
Any type of pool is going to be a serious investment. Homeowners need to know the pros and cons of each pool type. Should you install an above ground pool or an inground pool? Which requires less maintenance? Which is going to be the best long-term purchase?
We hope this guide will answer your questions. We’ve prepared an above ground vs inground pool comparison in 6 different categories. For each category, we’ve listed the pool type that we believe comes out on top. We suggest using this as a guide as you determine your pool priorities and consequently the best pool type for your yard.
1. Up-front Cost – Above Ground vs Inground
Inground pools often require extensive excavation and grading, as well as additional support in the form of retaining walls. As one would expect, this increases the up-front costs for inground pools considerably, leaving above ground pools as the unquestionable winner in this round. An average, 19’ diameter above ground pool will cost about $8,300. An average 12’ by 24’ inground pool will cost around $31,000. However, it’s worth noting that inground pool installation costs can extend almost as far as one’s imagination. If the pool is to simply be a wet spot for the kids, the costs will be far different than if it is to be the focal point of a grand outdoor entertainment area.
Winner: Above Ground Pools
2. Long Term Investment – Above Ground vs Inground
If you’re hoping to use your pool for decades, you’ll want to pay close attention to this particular comparison. A well-maintained in-ground pool can last 20 to 50 years, while an above ground pool typically lasts 10 to 15 years. Inground pools are also more resistant to damage since projectiles and sharp objects can puncture the vinyl sides of many above ground pools.
Interestingly, either pool type does not add much to resale value, so if you’re thinking this initial investment will also play out well when you go to sell…think again. Home buyers are usually split on whether or not they want a pool. While some buyers might pay more for a pool, others will see the pool as a liability. Don’t expect to see an increase in property value by adding a pool to your home. Rather look at what type of value it will add to your quality of life for yourself and your family while living in the home.
Winner: Inground Pools
3. Aesthetic Look – Above Ground vs Inground
Inground pools offer the most variety and customization when it comes to presentation. Your pool builder will often be able to add custom concrete or tile skirts so that your pool incorporates seamlessly into your yard. Nine times out of ten, homeowners prefer the pool to sit level with the yard.
However, you can still beautify your above ground pool with decks and wraparound siding. Many above ground pool owners prefer handsome wood frames, which also add extra safety compared to metal ladders.
Winner: Inground Pools
4. Installation – Above Ground vs Inground
Installing an above ground pool is much easier than installing an inground pool. Some homeowners with know-how can even set up an above ground pool on their own. A professional team can have you enjoying the water in as few as two days.
An inground pool, however, can take weeks. These pools require heavy machinery to dig out the site. Then professional concrete workers must install the walls and treat them to withstand being underwater.
Winner: Above Ground Pools
5. Maintenance – Above Ground vs Inground
Inground pools have a slight edge when it comes to maintenance. That said, maintaining water quality is similar regardless of your pool type. You still need to conduct regular cleaning, filtering, and chemical balancing.
The reason inground pools get the nod is because they can withstand more wear and tear compared to above ground pools. The inground concrete is highly durable. Kids, pets, and natural disasters, however, can easily puncture an above ground pool.
Winner: Inground Pools
6. Other Considerations – Above Ground vs Inground
You’ll want to check on city permits before installing a pool. Inground pools will almost always require a permit, which can be a hassle to obtain. Some areas require permits for above ground pools, but this is much less common.
You may also see an increase in home insurance depending on what type of pool you install.
Advice from a Pool Company in Dover, DE
Family Pool Maintenance works hard to help families have pools that are right for them. We know that so many decisions go into the pool installation process. If you still don’t know what type of pool is right for you, contact Family Pool Maintenance here. We work with quality professionals that do pool installation and we can help lead you in the right direction for your unique situation.
